According to Carol Venolia in her article Real Time in Natural Home Magazine, modern day society is moving away from direct experiences, such as actually spending time with our friends, and moving more towards indirect experiences such as chatting online instead. This distancing from real experiences, the author argues, creates a less satisfying and perhaps somewhat of a distorted life.
The idea of direct versus indirect experiences is very much tied into the concept of propinquity which was first introduced to me by Kevin Kellogg. Propinquity, if you’re unfamiliar with the word, “refers to the physical or psychological proximity between people” according to Wikipedia. It can only occur through direct experience. It can’t happen if you’re at home, chatting with your friends online while watching a reality show on mute and listening to satellite radio.
Why are propinquity and direct experience good? Why shouldn’t we just ride the wave of technology and allow it to distance us from the real world? Because according to Eric Storm, one of the founders of Create the Good Life,
“We’d probably all be a lot happier if we did more…simple, basic things. Whenever we can take the time to fully and directly experience something, we often feel more whole, connected and enriched.”
On an urban level, propinquity and direct experience create a much more vibrant and livable city. Those experiences involving personal interactions and direct sensory engagement are what give a city life. I found all sorts of examples of this in the cities I visited in Europe earlier this year. There seemed to be lots of opportunities to directly experience the city and also to be in proximity to other people. One huge factor contributing to this was simply the emphasis on walking/biking and public transit versus driving.
a typical street in Berlin
When there is a culture of walking or biking, it creates a default opportunity to share space with others. Walking and biking, according to the Natural Home article, are the most “direct” forms of transportation. Not only do they create space for propinquity, but they allow your body to be engaged in the city. For example, you can feel the pavement underneath your feet or your tires, you can hear the cars, you can smell the perfume or cologne of passersby, and feel the breeze on your face.
One of the reasons we lack direct experience and propinquity in Phoenix is our nonexistent walking and biking culture. Our car culture has cost us the fulfillment of our need to connect with the people and the world around us. For the most part, we drive with our windows closed due to the heat or cold and this literally creates a bubble separating us from our environment and other people. This bubble seems to have created a place of “auto-matons” – a disconnected, separate and disengaged populus. Is the convenience afforded by the car worth it?
Besides walking, transit is a fantastic opportunity for propinquity and direct experience. They happen while you’re waiting for your bus, surface or underground rail
bus stop in Brussels
rushing to get inside the bus in Berlin
at an S-Bahn (surface rail) station in Berlin (photo by Paul Loomans)
at a U-Bahn (underground rail) station in Berlin
and it happens when you actually get on the train or bus. What is interesting about being on the train or bus with others is how close you sometimes have to get to other people and sometimes actually touching the strangers around you is unavoidable. This can be annoying, sure, but it’s part of living in a city, part of sharing it with others. The human contact can, in fact, be a reminder that we are indeed in this world with other human beings, whether we like it or not.
With the advent of the Light Rail, we too can participate in the propinquity and direct experience created through the experience of taking transit. Yes, we’ve always had the bus system, but the Light Rail has expanded the opportunity and the actual usage of transit in the Valley. Waiting for the light rail is an extra-special experience in Phoenix because the stations are open and right in the middle of our busy streets. You can watch the traffic, feel the heat, experience a beautiful sunset and sometimes even strike up a conversation with a stranger who’s also waiting.
The best thing about actually being in the city, either by walking, taking transit or otherwise spending time in a public space, is that it puts you face to face with people you would normally never see or meet otherwise. It expands your personal experience from your carefully crafted, hand-selected group of friends and acquaintances to whole segments of the population you would never choose to stand next to. Sounds more annoying than anything else right? Well, perhaps. But at the same time, sharing space with people of all walks of life, different political backgrounds, different ethnicities, different sexual orientations and various economic situations has a tendency to humanize people that are different from you. It equalizes the platform, even if it’s just for a moment. And this is why propinquity and direct experience can have a normalizing effect on the human experience as opposed to the ever-distancing technological experience that we find so attractive.
Photo Credit: All photos by the author unless noted otherwise. Top photo taken inside the Phoenix Light Rail.